Business IEA Says Data Center Power Demand Could Double to 1,000 TWh by 2030, With AI Supplying Three Quarters of the Growth Chatbots ChatGPT Now Transcribes as You Talk: OpenAI Removes the 10-Minute Cap and Streams Words Live on Every Plan Business Ex-Alibaba Executive's Everful Raises $48.5 Million to Put AI Agents in Charge of Sourcing From 30,000 Factories AI Agents Google Built a Mirror Dimension of the Internet to Train Its Chrome AI Agents Without Breaking the Real Web Productivity Canva Finally Adds an Off Switch for Its Generative AI Features, and a Filter to Hide AI-Made Templates Business Anthropic Begins Trading Today: 980 Million Shares at $83, a $1.5 Trillion Valuation and the Largest IPO on Record News Google Books Blue Origin New Glenn to Launch TPU-Carrying AI Satellites in Early 2029 Security Hackers Used the AI Penetration Tool ARTEX to Disrupt European Commission Systems for Over Ten Days Business IEA Says Data Center Power Demand Could Double to 1,000 TWh by 2030, With AI Supplying Three Quarters of the Growth Chatbots ChatGPT Now Transcribes as You Talk: OpenAI Removes the 10-Minute Cap and Streams Words Live on Every Plan Business Ex-Alibaba Executive's Everful Raises $48.5 Million to Put AI Agents in Charge of Sourcing From 30,000 Factories AI Agents Google Built a Mirror Dimension of the Internet to Train Its Chrome AI Agents Without Breaking the Real Web Productivity Canva Finally Adds an Off Switch for Its Generative AI Features, and a Filter to Hide AI-Made Templates Business Anthropic Begins Trading Today: 980 Million Shares at $83, a $1.5 Trillion Valuation and the Largest IPO on Record News Google Books Blue Origin New Glenn to Launch TPU-Carrying AI Satellites in Early 2029 Security Hackers Used the AI Penetration Tool ARTEX to Disrupt European Commission Systems for Over Ten Days

Appeals Court Pauses Minnesota AI Imagery Ban in xAI Free-Speech Fight

Appeals Court Pauses Minnesota AI Imagery Ban in xAI Free-Speech Fight

The Eighth US Circuit Court of Appeals granted xAI an injunction pending appeal on October 2, pausing Minnesota's first-in-the-nation law against AI-generated intimate imagery while the company argues it violates the First Amendment. The law, effective August 1 with penalties up to $500,000 per violation, targets the tools that generate such images. xAI says Grok Imagine already blocks non-consensual output.

A US federal appeals court has put Minnesota's first-in-the-nation ban on AI-generated intimate imagery on hold, handing Elon Musk's xAI a procedural win while the company argues the statute violates the First Amendment. The St. Louis-based Eighth US Circuit Court of Appeals granted xAI's request for an injunction pending appeal on October 2, reversing — for now — a lower court's refusal to block enforcement.

Minnesota's anti-"nudification" law took effect on August 1. It bars website operators, software developers and other service providers from letting users create realistic images that depict an intimate body part not shown in an original photo of an identifiable person, and it targets the tool that generates the image rather than only the person who circulates it. Violations carry penalties of up to $500,000 each under the state framework.

The procedural history has moved quickly. Minnesota enacted the measure on January 15; xAI shipped updated safeguards for its Grok Imagine image tool on February 10; the company filed a federal suit against Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison on August 12. US District Judge Donovan Frank denied emergency relief on September 4, finding that xAI had not shown irreparable harm and had waited too long to seek an order. xAI appealed on September 15, and the appellate court's October 2 order suspends enforcement while the merits are argued.

xAI's argument is twofold: that the statute sweeps too broadly as a restriction on protected expression, and that Grok Imagine already carries what the company calls rigorous protections against generating sexualised images of real people without consent. xAI says it has begun suing users it alleges are evading those blockers. Minnesota has countered that the law is needed to curb a "staggering amount" of non-consensual sexual imagery, including material involving minors, produced by AI tools such as Grok Imagine.

Legal analysts describe the ruling as a pause rather than a verdict. The Eighth Circuit has not decided whether the statute is constitutional; it has concluded only that the law should not be enforced while that question is litigated. Minnesota's attorney general has publicly expressed disappointment at the outcome, and further appellate hearings are expected in the coming weeks.

The case sits at the front edge of a broader fight between state legislatures and AI developers over who may regulate model outputs. Content-based restrictions on speech face strict scrutiny in US courts, and drafters who want to survive that standard are likely to be pushed toward narrow, harm-specific definitions — targeting a demonstrated injury rather than a broad class of tools. For AI companies, the practical question is whether a compliance regime built on liability for the generating tool is workable at all, and whether courts will let states experiment with it while the answer is unresolved.

Comments (0)

Log in to join the discussion

Log In

No comments yet